Wednesday, February 13, 2008

How to get an Instructional Design education without paying tuition

Well, yesterday Cammy has responded to my post on the disconnect between academic instructional design and practical instructional design. Subsequently, the last five hours or so has been interesting. First of all, I see that Stephen Downes has mentioned our conversation on OLD~Daily, and that has led to a number of comments on my blog as well as others posting about them on their blogs.

I've got to admit, I'm enjoying thinking about these questions.

Wendy Wickham from In the Middle of the Curve has joined the conversation. Wendy has an MA in Instructional Technology from Towson University (I don't think I know anyone on that faculty). Wendy makes a good point saying:

How I use theory - selling my instructional design ideas.

People respond to jargon. And, interestingly, people love learning other people's jargon. I had never seen such an excited group of people as the day I introduced ADDIE to the Project Management group and related that process to how they do business.

Do I use ADDIE? Not always - but it does seem to be a nice way to keep track of the status of my ID projects.

Citing academic theory makes it sound like you are putting more effort into it than "I dunno - this just made sense. Whadya think?"

Do I need my MS in Instructional Technology to practice? No. The theoretical ammunition I received in that program helps.


Great point. I had the same experience working with some military officials earlier this year. But later Cammy responds:

I completely agree that this stuff impresses clients. I use it all the time.

But one can learn the jargon without going to grad school. And one can cite the academic theory by reading and staying informed.

Perhaps the (somewhat cynical) question to ask is -- what's the right amount of jargon needed to get by? Do I need to know all of the things on John's list?

Personally, I don't think so. I've gotten by well enough without most of those theories, it seems.

This comes back to my quest from last year of getting an informal masters in ID.

If one were to construct an informal, self-paced, DIY instructional design curriculum, what content would you include?


So Cammy, only because I'm a big fan of yours, I present How to get an Instructional Design education without paying tuition.First of all, let me reference some previous posts from my blog.

On April 1, 2006 I posted What my graduate students need to know. Specifically, on that post I'd pay attention to the suggested self-study program for Instructional Systems Development (ISD) by M. David Merrill (Yeah, I know, I keep referencing him in things, but it's hard not to, he taught me design!). It's outdated to a degree, but it has a solid foundation. He's since given me a list of books to add to it, but I can't find it right now. (Note to self: LOOK FOR IT!)

Next, when I was designing the EDTC 5203: Foundations of Educational Technology course here at Oklahoma State, I posted my Reading list for Foundations of Educational Technology. I later followed that post with Foundations readings revisited, in which I pointed people to Trends and Issues in Instructional Design and Technology, 2nd Edition. Specifically appropriate for this discussion is chapter 32 of the text: The Future of Instructional Design (which I referenced in my original post). Also in that chapter was Merrill's breakdown of the proper study of instructional design. I posted my responses to the chapter in June 2006. According to that chapter, I would be considered an instructional scientist to Cammy's instructional technologist.

With that said, if I wanted someone to get an instructional design education without paying tuition, here would be my list of must haves:

Disclaimer: In these last series of posts, I am in NO WAY saying that it isn't necessary or beneficial to have academic training.  I actually had Tyler Wardle, of our Ph.D. recruits,  tell me last night that I shouldn't have posted what I did until he actually entered our program (or someone else's).  So perhaps I wasn't clear.  I do believe the theory informs practice, and that knowing the theory should make you a better designer.  When I commented that it wouldn't make a difference, I was speaking directly to Cammy.  I was saying that she seems smart enough that it probably wouldn't make a difference to her situation.

So there you have it, Cammy. I hope this helps.

Comments, anyone? What did I leave off?

41 comments:

  1. John, wonderful, wonderful list.

    Here's my two cents' on this topic; it's a beef with many instructional designers today.

    I think many instructional designers use their knowledge of instructional-design theories and models to make the conversation about learning today smaller rather than bigger, especially about new technologies.

    I think there are conversations about new information, communication, and entertainment technologies that instructional designers, by and large, don't participate in.

    My conversations with instructional designers about search (Google), video (YouTube), immersive environments (Second Life), social networking (Facebook), games, blogging, wikis, etc., etc, typically consist of the instructional designer frowning and saying, "That's not instruction," or, "That doesn't fit with what we know about good instruction."

    Instructional-design theories and models seem to create partisanship, kind of like a French chef who doesn't have anything to say about pizza because it's not French cooking.

    So we have these short, this-does-not-fit-the-tradition-I-was-raised-in conversations.

    I never hear anyone say anything conceptually pluralistic like, "I come from a Gagne perspective so I don't see Google as a learning tool because it's not instruction, but I can see from a performance-support perspective how it's the world's biggest learning tool."

    Or, "I come from an instructivist perspective and think in terms of delivery, so I don't think of Second Life as an instructional platform, but I can see how constructivists are interested in learners constructing 3D experiences in Second Life."

    I think it's fair to ask, what do others know about instructional design.

    But I think it's also fair to ask, what do instructional designers know about game design theory, information design theory, performance-support design theory, social network theory, and so forth.

    So that when we encounter different world-views in our field it's the beginning of the conversation, not the end of it.

    End of rant. Thanks again for the great list.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Maybe including competencies of an instructional designer would be a good addition to the list? The International Board of Standards for Training, Performance, and Instruction (ibstpi.org) published the "Instructional Design Competencies" (2001) by Richey, Fields, & Foxon that I use.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dr. John -- what a daunting list! Where is a poor girl to begin? Frankly, I think I'd have to be in a program in order to maintain the discipline and focus to get through it all. What are the basics? Whittle it down even more for me...

    ReplyDelete
  4. [...] How to get an Instructional Design education without paying tuition [...]

    ReplyDelete
  5. [...] the thought of making my writing “tighter.” So while the purpose of my initial post on how to get an instructional design education without paying tuition was meant as a “here’s what you need to know,” I still missed the [...]

    ReplyDelete
  6. [...] How to get an Instructional Design education without paying tuition | effectivedesign.org [...]

    ReplyDelete
  7. [...] it’s worth it. Now, just to be clear, this has nothing to do with John’s post, “How to Get an Instructional Design Education Without Paying Tuition“. Really, it doesn’t. I just love my current job and am scared about what life will [...]

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi Dr. Curry,

    Thank you for your list. It looks like I have a lot of reading to do.

    Although I cannot claim I am an "instructional designer," I design instruction daily at the front lines of public education in the classroom.

    IMHO, there is no other method to mastery in any field than apprentice with a master or several masters and then practice, practice, practice.

    So who are the masters?

    Here's a list of several of my favorites:

    Physlrnr - a listserv of dynamic physics educators discussing what works at the cutting edge of science education.

    VanTH/ERC - an engineering research consortium between Vanderbilt, Northwestern, MIT and Harvard promoting challenge-based bioengineering curriculum development based on the "How People Learn" Legacy Cycle.

    Concord Consortium - a group dedicated to deep, persistent understandings through the use of interactive math and science visualization tools

    One might argue that these are domain specific, but I would point them to your idea so well expressed above:

    "What Engineers Know and How They Know it, by Walter G. Vincenti. A book on how engineers solve design problems. After all, aren’t we educational engineers?"

    Ciao,

    Gregory

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you that teachers design and practice instructional techniques daily. I do think that the term "instructional design" is more geared towards the business industry rather than education. Not to say that education couldn't use a dose of ADDIE or SAM but as a teacher myself, we are often told when and why to build a course. We as educators do not dig for that information ourselves although we are expected to analyze results. Maybe that makes us partial instructional designers.

      Delete
  9. [...] would be a great fit with Cammy Bean’s dialog with Dr. John Curry and [...]

    ReplyDelete
  10. Have you see this ( http://www.bookstoread.com/e/et/top10id.htm ) which is the Top 10 ID books from some of the leaders in ID?

    ReplyDelete
  11. [...] instructional design and certification. They were interested in the conversations Cammy Bean and I have had about those topics, and wondered where those conversations were going. Today Cammy e-mailed me, [...]

    ReplyDelete
  12. Doesn't a list of books dismiss the whole idea of a need to practice and experience to enhance learning? It's a bit of a putoff....

    ReplyDelete
  13. Wow that is quite a list.However it is helpfull one for a novice like me staying in country that has few programmes for Instructional designing.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thanks you for this post and the list of ID 'must haves.' I have an M.Ed. in Instructional Technology Design. Recently started re-reading my old ID textbooks. And doing some internet searches for Instructional Designer Competencies. There is so much.

    I have only been a 'degree-d' ID for 3 years--but I know it is my professional obligation to stay knowledgeable about past and present practices and research. For instructional design and eLearning. This post really means alot. Its 3:42 am. I can rest and start on this list tomorrow.

    Thanks again,

    De Anna

    ReplyDelete
  15. I love this topic. Can't avoid weighing in.

    Full disclosure-- admit that I have taught ID in an EDTEC program at SDSU for 30+ years. Time flies when you are having fun.

    Obviously, I have much invested in believing that what we did there was meaningful to our students and to the field.

    It's not just the student experiences and growth, although that is first and foremost. It's also the expectations that faculty will contribute to thought leadership. You write about Dave Merrill. Great example. Consider my colleague Bernie Dodge and his work on Webquests. This list could go on and on.

    And one more thing.

    A book list (and this is a nice one) does not a curriculum make. How about practice, feedback, repeated practice over time, and a community? Good programs do that.

    By the way, you mention my old book Training Needs Assessment. I've written two since: editions 1 and 2 of First Things Fast: A Handbook for Performance Analysis.

    allison

    ReplyDelete
  16. The 21st century incline takes a gander at the estimation of imagination in an individual sense as a contributing variable to society and riches creation as opposed to the structures of rivalry. That is the reason it is not shocking that 21st century instructors utilize online training thoroughly as a medium to bring their message. Online instruction is constantly testing conventional techniques for training. fake degree

    ReplyDelete
  17. Past general courses now it is coming to be essential to get instruction and learning in the fresh out of the box new spots which were prior considered as practice as it were. One of such illustration is of Entrepreneur Education.
    supremedissertation.co.uk

    ReplyDelete
  18. This is often as a result of the academics and people who undertake the masters program get abundant improved teaching skills and analysis strategies. This directly affects completely the scholars they teach.
    learning

    ReplyDelete
  19. Not only will it save the retailer time and money but also the client. For example, by seeing their plan in 3D on the computer, the client can get a real-life feel for their new room in actual dimensions, they can even add furniture, appliances and their own colour schemes.buy SolidWorks 2013

    ReplyDelete
  20. People respond to jargon. And, interestingly, people love learning other people's jargon. microsoft office training

    ReplyDelete
  21. One of those online diaries that has left a significant impact on the hearts of the individuals.
    dissertation writing help

    ReplyDelete
  22. Our school provides all the services in very low prices, large number of educational institute also provide the same services but price is not same. For more information about this education and our educational programs then you must visit our website. Write English Essays

    ReplyDelete
  23. Great post I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this interesting and knowledgeable article. Kerala Ration Card Status

    ReplyDelete
  24. Fearless and shocking in comparable measures, an undeniable necessity read.
    essaywriters

    ReplyDelete
  25. Because effective proposals can lead to immediate business, this sales development tool can serve as a key strategy for reviving businesses during a vulnerable period. kenyan research papers

    ReplyDelete
  26. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  27. For instance, Education International, the real umbrella gathering of educators' unions and relationship on the planet. http://charankel.page4.me/ has issued a revelation and activity intend to advance manageable improvement through instruction.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Thanks a bunch for this article. Kindly keep it available and keep

    on posting articles like this.i am looking forward to your next

    blog

    http://indian-matka.net/mumbai-guessing-forum.php

    ReplyDelete
  29. Dimmock & Walker (2005) argue that in a globalizing and internalizing world, it is not only business and industry that are changing, education, too, is caught up in that new order. personal shopper

    ReplyDelete
  30. loans without guarantor

    You have made some decent points there. I checked on the web to find out more about the issue and found most individuals will go along with your views on this site.

    ReplyDelete
  31. While each main subjects will contrast from school to class, most training degree programs educational website incorporate courses in every single applicable part of instruction.

    ReplyDelete
  32. through adjusting their direction and http://earlyeducationtips.com/ materials and having somewhat more tolerance and sympathy.

    ReplyDelete
  33. I needed to thank you for this phenomenal read!! I unquestionably adored each and every piece of it. I have you bookmarked your site to look at the new stuff you post. luyện ielts hcm

    ReplyDelete
  34. A man enters the field of education as a calling - either full time in customary scholarly establishments or as a subordinate (or low maintenance) teacher.Vested Finance LLC

    ReplyDelete
  35. We therefore need to clarify the concept of education for sustainable development. course deals

    ReplyDelete
  36. The more typical education IRA which is preceding the Economic Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001 just permits guardians a most extreme yearly commitment of $ 500motivational

    ReplyDelete
  37. History has shown that this has never been an easy clear cut relationship between the two. REET

    ReplyDelete
  38. Intended for light utilize, a home paper shredder ordinarily obliges the light obligation destroying necessities of one to two individuals and acknowledges 3 to 10 sheets of standard measured paper on the double. Micro Cut Paper Shredder

    ReplyDelete